Wednesday, 29 September 2010

Review: On the Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta [Audiobook]

On the Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta [Audiobook]



Genre:Contemporary > Social Issues
Age Group:13+
Publisher:Penguin
Release Date: 2006
Form: Audiobook on CDs
Source: Local Library
ISBN: 9780670070299

Rating: 

 

Cover love? The cover is of an artistic road, with figures in both the background and foreground. But, the road is not what I imagine the Jellicoe Road to be. However, I love the layout, contrasts and tone - the cover makes a beautiful artwork.






"What do you want from me?" he asks. 

What I want from every person in my life, I want to tell him. 

More. 

Taylor Markham is not a popular choice. She is erratic, has no people skills and never turns up to meetings. Not to mention the incident when she ran off in search of her mother and only got halfway there. But she's lived at Jellicoe School most of her life and as leader of the boarders that's her greatest asset. Especially now the cadets, led by the infamous Jonah Griggs, have arrived. The territory wars between the boarders, townies and cadets are about to recommence. 

But Taylor has other things on her mind: a prayer tree, the hermit who whispered in her ear, and a vaguely familiar drawing in the local police station. Taylor wants to understand the mystery of her own past. But Hannah, the woman who found her, has suddenly disappeared, leaving nothing but an unfinished manuscript about five kids whose lives entwined twenty years ago on the Jellicoe Road. - from Melina Marchetta's site.




I actually listened to an audiobook version of On the Jellicoe Road, lovingly borrowed from the local library, of course.

The narrator was Rebecca Macauley, and I believe that she is one of the best audiobook narrators out there. When you're listening to an audiobook, the believability and skill of the narrator is of paramount importance. No matter how good the book is, the person narrating it can alter the listener's entire perspective of the book.

For example, The Hunger Games is without question, one of the greatest books I have ever read. One of the reasons is due to the relatability of Katniss' voice. When I'm reading Suzanne Collins' words, I feel as if I am hearing Katniss. But when I heard the audiobook version, I felt that the narrator's voice didn't suit what I imagined Katniss to sound like. I couldn't relate to it, and so I stopped listening.

But with Macauley's reading, I felt that the Australian setting, the characters, and the moving story came through in her voice. It didn't feel like someone was reading a book to me; it felt as if Taylor Markham and Nanie were telling me their story. Macauley's voice captures the essence of On The Jellicoe Road in an authentic way that draws the listener right into the story.

The story alternates between the life of Taylor Markham, and the story of a group of friends in the eighties. Thus, the story is at times broken and a little confusing, but the end result is two complex, immersive storeis that join together to form one.

The characters and setting are distinguishably Australian. They feel natural to me - perfect characters in that they are imperfect people. The characterisation here is also beautiful - they each have thier individual voices, style and personality. There's never any confusion between the characters, despite their number. I loved each and every one of them - Taylor, Jonah Greggs, Raffy, Santangelo, Jessa, Nanie, Tate, Fitz, Jude, Web.

My one concern is that to me, Taylor felt a lot like Josephine Alibrandi from Looking For Alibrandi. Their personalities were very similar, and it felt like the same character in two different stories. They were both rebellious, confused, loyal, loving, Australian teens. They both faced some form of social issue, despite the two books being vastly different within the same genre.

Melina Marchetta's writing style is very characteristic in that sense, but it always speaks of truth, pain and love, and her use of words and dialogue propels the story forward, and paints the scene in the recipient's mind.

A story of discovering the truth, finding love, and making friends along the way.


Rating: 



200 followers

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
This story just sounds so mysterious and full of atmosphere. I've heard of it, but never quite like this. You've made it sound really interesting. This must be the Australian cover, because I think the US has a different one. Nice wrap-up. It makes me more interested in reading it. Oh, thank you so much for your kind words about my blog. That was very sweet of you. I'm glad you like it. I try my best to make it interesting for people and with you, I see I've succeeded. Thanks so very much!
Oh, I just love this book and youve done such a brilliant job reviewing it. I've never done an audio book -not sure why?

Have you read saving Francesca by Melina Marchetta? I think you'd really like that :)

Also, side comment here: how did you get the reply button in your comments? I'd love that feature but haven't noticed it as an optoin in my blogger dashboard thingy. Youre a genius like that :)

xx
2 replies · active 756 weeks ago
Oh! just realised youre using the intense debate thingy...
Would you like a tutorial on Intense Debate? I was thinking of doing one...
I love, love, love this book (it's Melina Marchetta, after all).
I really want to listen to this on audio book now, you've reviewed it so brilliantly. Great stuff!
Brilliant review! I too listened to this on audio and LOVED it. You should listen to Saving Franchesca as well - as I believe it is the same narrator. Melina is one of my new favorite authors and I really need to read Finnikin of the Rock as well. :) Thanks for stopping by my blog today! :)
Lovely review, Tina. I'm pining for this book; I've heard brilliant things about it. I usually don't read much contemporary YA but I really should try to.
Love your insight on audio books! I haven't ever listened to any but it certainly makes sense. I will have to try some! Thanks for coming by today! :)
The Delusional Diaries
Hi! New follower--what an adorable blog! And I loved your review of Jellicoe Road (which has been on my TBR pile for a while but keeps getting buried under newer books--it's moving to the top).

Thanks for stopping by my blog, too! :)
I'm an audio book fan myself. I might have to check this one out. Thanks!
I definitely definitely agree -- a narrator means everything! If they have a very monotone voice.. I lose interest and might as well read the book myself!
I've yet to read this book, but I hear amazing things about this. The story sounds so heartfelt! Great review :)
Great review! I'm not an audiobook fan, but I've heard from others that Hunger Games just isn't the same with the narrator they chose. The narrator can make or break an audiobook, I'm sure!
I haven't tried audiobooks before (although I've heard snippets of a few, one of them being The Hunger Games, and I totally agree about the voice not relating, hence why I didn't buy it). I loved On The Jellicoe Road was an awesome book and you reviewed it really well! I haven't read Looking For Alibrandi though.
I've got this on my to read list because my partner went on about it quite a bit. I''ve so far only read Looking For Alibrandi even though Marchetta has so many books. I always worry about authors re-using characters or character traits even when they don't mean to, but other then that your review sounds promising.

I'm so glad that the audio was good for you because I have heard that it all depends on the voice and delivery quite a bit. It's a shame that something like that can determine whether you enjoy it or not.
You are so right about the importance of the narrator when it comes to audiobooks...for me its a deal breaker, even if it is a book I know I will like, if the narrator is blah...

Post a new comment

Comments by