Sunday, 12 September 2010

Review: Mockingjay by Suzanne Collins

So here I am, thinking that a review shouldn't be this damn hard to write. But hey. It's Mockingjay...only the most anticipated book of the year!


Title: Mockingjay
Author: Suzanne Collins
Series: The Hunger Games Trilogy
--Book 1: The Hunger Games
--Book 2: Catching Fire
--Book 3: Mockingjay
Source: Borrowed from friend

Blurb (Goodreads):
"Against all odds, Katniss Everdeen has survived the Hunger Games twice. But now that she’s made it out of the bloody arena alive, she’s still not safe. The Capitol is angry. The Capitol wants revenge. Who do they think should pay for the unrest? Katniss. And what’s worse, President Snow has made it clear that no one else is safe either. Not Katniss’s family, not her friends, not the people of District 12. Powerful and haunting, this thrilling final installment of Suzanne Collins’s groundbreaking The Hunger Games trilogy promises to be one of the most talked about books of the year."



On the cover: I had to very reluctantly peeled my eyes off the pure, glossy cover, to devour the first page of the story. Considering the brilliance I was awaiting after Catching Fire, I believe that is enough said.


Review:
I could go on forever about this book, but by now everyone has probably read this book, so I'll make it into a discussion about three of the main elements in this book.

1. Katniss
Over the span of the two books, I had come to regard Katniss as an extremely resourceful, rebellious and intelligent character. She had me hooked from the beginning. Her admirable personality, the ability to persevere under the dire circumstances, her strong sense of individuality.

Katniss changed in Mockingjay. She flashed briefly as the iconic leader of the rebellion. But that was all she was - an icon for the masses. Was she there when the other Districts rebelled? Did she know how they rebelled?

No. She was stuck in 13, putting on clothes and make up to film propaganda, in between her blank, numb spots of depression, while being obligingly oppressed by President Coin.

I suppose I was just unsatisfied with Katniss' reduction as a character that I had grown to love. She was still resilient, but less so.

Perhaps I'm taking this change too close to the heart. Katniss is just a fictional character, in a far-off dystopian world. But it's a tribute to Suzanne Collins' brilliance as an author that I feel so strongly about Katniss' change.

The truth of Katniss' emotions resonates with me, though. After everything she has been through, her post-traumatic stress disorder is utterly understandable. It is a miracle that she was able to hold on for another Hunger Games in Book 2.

2. Death
The second thing I want to talk about is death. The death of so many characters in this novel was very JK Rowling. Characters that I loved were executed with a strike of Collins' pen.

The death toll rose before my eyes. I felt as if there was a death list, and every time I turned the page, someone else would be dropping dead before me. Cinna, Finnick, and Primrose's deaths were the most shocking. I kept waiting for them to reappear. It was Deathly Hallows all over again.
 
The deaths, combined with Katniss' continued depression, and a heavy coat of rebellious subject matter, made the story seem absolutely real tome. It was dark, and scary and truthful.

3. The Ending

Let me show you this in a metaphorical story:

After several years of laborious work, Collins had woven a complex and beautiful tapestry of a world that amazed all who cast their eyes upon it, using the magic of her mind. As she neared the end of her depiction, she realised that she no longer had enough string to complete the story. And so she hastily tied up the loose threads that still hung free, in a knot that she had seen many others perform before.

When her masterpiece had been completed, people were awed by the truth and dark themes that resounded from the tapestry's colours. They revelled in the beauty that the magic of her words had created.

But at the very end, they saw the hasty knots, and the threads that hung forgotten and vague.

Some still admired the tapestry for it's beauty. But some were disappointed.

And I was one of them. 


And that's what I have to say about Mockingjay. Not really a review...but a disjointed discussion. I still loved this book - the series on the whole was mind-blowing, but I felt the end was somehow anticlimactic. 

Rating:  ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ 

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I totally respect your thoughts on Mockingjay, and I loved this review. While I loved Mockingjay and thought it was a fitting conclusion to such a dark book, I could definitely see that she was hurriedly finishing it, and it felt rushed at the end - too rushed.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
You're right....it felt rushed, but the dark conclusion was appropriate for a novel of this depth.
Hey Tina, I've passed an award along to you! See here for more info: http://atapestryofwords.blogspot.com/2010/09/awar.... Congrats!
1 reply · active 759 weeks ago
There's a blog award waiting for you over at my blog. Keep it shiny!
http://aboutbooksblog.blogspot.com/2010/09/anothe...
1 reply · active 759 weeks ago
Meh, I just ignore the epilogue. I really wish that Katniss was allowed to defend herself at her hearing. If that scene would have been written, it might have been the most powerful scene in the book. Imagine all of katniss friends, family (what's left =/ ) either defending her or speaking out against her. Imagine her speaking her mind and for once not being played as a pawn. It would have been incredible, but nope, that's not what we got and I agree with you, it was really rushed.

I just want to know what Gale's doing in the future. He's really the only character I truly liked and didn't waver. Not that I was ever on "team gale" but he just seemed so honest and blunt.
1 reply · active 759 weeks ago
I love your reply, Najela.

That would have been a great and powerful scene...I'd love to have read it too...what a fantastic idea.

And true...the only mention of Gale we got was that he was doing something important in District 2. He was a great charaacter, there should have been more time allocated to him.
I understand where you are coming from with being a little disappointed but let me ask you, where could the story have gone? We already got to see a little bit of "after the battle" with the first half of Mockingjay. I imagine at first, most of Katniss's days were like that and she slowly recovers. After such an action packed and shocking book, I'm not sure we could get an ending that we could be completely happy with. I seem to be one of the few who don't mind the ending we got.

Thanks for the review!
The ending worked for me. I found it hopeful. Glad you stumbled by today!
You are the first reviewer Ive seen that so nicely encapsulated the feeling I had when I read this book too.
I intended to review it, but finally just let it go cause of how hte ending flat-lined for me.
I couldnt find the words to express it, so I'm glad you did :)
e-Volving Books
I loved Mockingjay, I really did. Still, I feel the same way as you do which is to say disappointed. I really wanted Katniss to be more than she was in this book.

Post a new comment

Comments by