Monday, 20 September 2010

Review: Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher

UK cover
US Cover

Thirteen Reasons Why by Jay Asher

Genre:Young Adult - Contemporary
Interest:Debut novel
Age Group:13+
Publisher:Razorbill Penguin
Release Date: 2007
Pages: 288
Cover love? My edition of Thirteen Reasons Why is the one shown on the right - the UK one. And I have to say that it looks a little morbid, which is probably the reasons why I didn't immediately pick it up and read it. But after reading the book, I think this cover is perfect. However, the US cover looks brighter, one I would probably pick up immediately. 


Synopsis
Clay Jensen returns home from school to find a mysterious box with his name on it lying on his porch. Inside he discovers cassette tapes recorded by Hannah Baker—his classmate and crush—who committed suicide two weeks earlier.

On tape, Hannah explains that there are thirteen reasons why she decided to end her life. Clay is one of them. If he listens, he’ll find out how he made the list.

Through Hannah and Clay’s dual narratives, debut author Jay Asher weaves an intricate and heartrending story of confusion and desperation that will deeply affect teen readers.

Review
Thirteen Reasons Why is a strikingly truthful account of teenage troubles. It's not a happy, fluffy comtemporary novel - it's a sad, haunting story with themes of sexual abuse and suicide. It will make your heart wrench and your tears flow, because it's filled with so much truth and sadness.

The book occurs over one night, as Clay Jensen is listening to Hannah's tapes. The format of this book is in alternating first person perspectives, from Clay's thoughts, to those of Hannah Baker, as told to us through what Clay hears from the cassette tapes. We get the story from Hannah's voice, and the reactions and alternate point of view from Clay. The alternating POVs were clear and served their purpose well, contrary to the confusion commonly induced with alternating first-person narratives.

Jay Asher's decision to tell the story in this way is both original and enticing, setting this book apart from many others that I've read. Hannah and Clay's voices are exceedingly believable. I could almost hear them in my mind as I was reading the book, and I credit this to Jay Asher's immense ability to give personality to his characters through their prose. Hannah was personified well - although she was in her grave, her voice in was witty, snarky and had a dry humour that made me like her immensely. I wanted to reach through the pages and console her.

Clay never receded into the background, because when he listened to the tapes, he was recounting and redefining his concept of Hannah. Although the book was from his perspective, Hannah was the main character.

Hannah told us everything that happened to her - all the events that in combination, lead to her decision to kill herself. The plot seemed like a string of unfortunate events, but there were twists and turns that caused me to gasp and clutch my book harder. Although two particular scenes dark subject matters, it was told in a way that wasn't perverse or explicit. It was told through the impact that it had on Hannah.

I can't quite put my finger on what exactly makes me love so much. I guess it was a combination of Hannah's resounding and real voice, the beautiful but sad tale and the unique format of the book. It's a beautifully emotive book that will forever remain in my heart.

Rating:

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Thank you for this great review, Tina. I think 13 Reasons Why sounds like a good read but I'm such a wimp when it comes to reading about abuse so I'm not sure if this is a book for me.
1 reply · active 758 weeks ago
Aww! Thirteen Reasons Why isn't that bad on abuse - only two scenes. But it's a great, sad, sweet book.
I have 13 Reasons Why on my TBR list for quite a while now but something else always comes up and I end up not reading it.I'd love to though, it sounds great!
Thanks for the review!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Thank YOU for reading.
A great review! I've heard about this book in passing, but never really looked harder at it! I just might pick it up!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
Yay! That's awesome, Brittany.
I loved this book. It was one of the first non-fantasy/paranormal novels i read in the YA genre and it broke my heart. The end left me feeling changed and as mush as I wanted Hannah to be alive, I knew she wasn't and it just a lot. I really enjoyed listening to the tapes with Clay and seeing the same things he did through Hannah's eyes. I was also really intrigued to figure out why he'd be on the tape and was so glad when I finally did see. I agree that Asher was masterful at telling two different sides to the story in an interesting and exciting way. Great review Tina!
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
I love love LOVE this comment, Amber. You express my thoughts in a way that I can't yet. I guess I breathed a sigh of relief when I found out that he hasn't done anyting horrible to Hannah.
I guess it's always like that - the main character never is truly "bad". I've yet to read a book where the protagonist is evil - there's always some good there. I guess authors are subliminally telling us that there's good in everyone.
Great review. I have been seeing this one around and it really hasn't caught my attention. Now I will have to add it to my never ending TBR pile! Thanks for joining the September Spectacular!!
I have this book, waiting to be read. I should really push it up. Have heard so many good things about it!
Great review. This is one of my favorite books.
Found you on Lori's Linky for Show Me The Money Fun.

Cute blog....never visited before.
Great review...this sounds like a book sure to provoke discussion...would you say that it is appropriate for the younger end of the YA age spectrum?
I LOVE the look of this blog, and I'm RSSing right now. Thanks for the reviews.
Informative review, great job! I'm putting this on my tbr list. --btw, just in case you're looking for ideas on tip post ( :D )...how'd you box your synopsis?... and how do you make those heart ratings (perfect for me..see my blog url)?--please don't say paint cuz I've fiddled with mine and I'm hopeless there!!

Bunches of thanks!! =]
Jinky is reading
great review, i've read this book before and I also liked reading it. It was a break from the normal triangle romance books out there (that i also love)
Also participating in the September Spectacular Challenge. A great review, I much prefer the UK cover and not just because I'm English.

Post a new comment

Comments by